Mensa & Mirrors

Mensagenda columnist (and communications officer) Mat Rouch wrote an article for the September issue on a topic that fascinates lots of people, including him and me. He asked, “Why do mirrors reverse left-right but not up-down?” The article is available online in the members’-only section of the chapter website, http://www.mnmensa.org/.

I’d like to hear other members’ responses, so do read the whole thing (the article starts on page 18), and sound off in the comments. Mat’s conclusion:

And finally, when you look at your reflection in your bedroom mirror you do not perceive it as a flat image of the room you are in (which would be correct). You perceive it as a space behind the mirror. And the only rotational axis you can choose that (a) allows you to preserve the direction of gravity, (b) keeps the image of your bilaterally symmetric self still looking reasonable and (c) retains a sense of the reflection being a volume behind the mirror is the left-right axis. So that’s the one your brain chooses for you, automatically and beyond your control. That’s my story and I’m sticking to it.

It’s a fine story. But it’s not much like mine. I said:

If someone were standing next to you, walked forward past the plane of the mirror, turned around, and walked back to stand “next to” the apparent position of the mirror image, his right hand would be to your left. But the work here is being done by “turned around” — that is, he performed a 180-degree rotation around a vertical axis, and thus reversed both front-to-back and right-to-left. Your reflection in the mirror did not turn around, so it reversed only front-to-back. (If you have a ring on your left hand, and reach out and touch the mirror, the image-hand you touch also has a ring, and it is to the left in the mirror.) But it would be the ringless right hand of a person who turned around, and that is how your brain interprets it.

Mat responded:

I think your analysis is precisely correct as a description of what a reflection is, but what I wanted to get across is why the human brain insists on interpreting it as a left-right reversal as opposed to any other axis, when others are perfectly valid. You want to interpret what you see as a space behind the mirror (which it isn’t) and the only sensible way you can do that, bilaterally symmetrical and stuck in a strong gravitational field as you are, is by swapping left-right. Flip up-down and not only is your head facing the wrong way, everything is stuck to the ceiling.
The four-armed starfish does not have that limitation. He lives more or less in zero-g and his head looks just like his feet. If he swapped up-down the result would be a perfectly reasonable space-behind-the-mirror, and the same would be true if he swapped left-right. So he could and probably would do either one, as appropriate.

There you go. Your turn!

About linsee

Linda Seebach retired in 2007 from the Rocky Mountain News in Denver, where she was an editorial writer and columnist.
This entry was posted in Minnesota Mensa and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Mensa & Mirrors

  1. Mark Paris says:

    I can’t get to the members’ section, but this is an old one. The correct answer is that mirrors do not reverse left and right or up and down, they reverse in an out. Here is a simple thought experiment: stand before a mirror holding an arrow. Point the arrow to your right. The arrow in the mirror point to your right. Point the arrow down. The mirror arrow points down. Point the arrow directly into the mirror. The mirror arrow point out of the mirror.

  2. Jim Malone says:

    I find the convoluted explanations far more interesting, psychologically, than the thought problem itself. I explain it as follows: Nothing is reversed; not left and right; not up and down. If one lies down in front of mirror, the “trick” is revealed (at least it was for me). “Left” and “right” are relative directions only. When one raises one’s right hand, the hand on the right in the reflection raises as it must. No reversal. We are hardwired to resolve human images and the reflection is resolved as a person facing and relative to the “person” in the reflection, our brains reason that “his” or “her” left hand was raised. We can’t help it.

  3. Joachim Leo Sommerfeld says:

    Applying Occam’s Razor, I find the following answer:

    Light travels in straight lines only. (Never mind gravitational lensing for this one.) Thus, the reflection from the left side of your face will travel straight to the left side of the mirror, the right side to the right. Then, it travels in straight lines right back to you. Of necessity, what reflects from the mirror back to you is reversed side to side. Top and bottom remain right where they are, as you would expect.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>